Musa al-Gharbi / New York City

A man with a beard and glasses wearing a white shirt, looking thoughtful against a dark background.
A man with a beard and glasses wearing a white shirt, looking thoughtful against a dark background.

I had resolved fairly early on that my plan in life was to become a priest. In preparation, I went to regular Bible studies for years. I was also an altar server in the Catholic Church.

The problem was that after I graduated from high school, when I was getting ready to enter seminary, I started having a crisis of faith. Through my engagement with scripture, I had become convinced that Jesus probably didn’t understand himself to be God.

You had a serious vocational pull?

Oh, yeah. It was very serious. I had been mentored by Father Greg, one of the local priests at St. Andrew’s, and we had been preparing for this for years.

I didn’t have a Plan B. This was the plan.

I talked to the local priests as I was having these theological struggles. We tried to work through them, but I just couldn’t shake the feeling. Eventually, I stepped back from that path.

I basically convinced myself that religion as a whole was bullshit and that there was no God. I really tried to live as if there was no God, in a kind of Dostoevskian way: if there is no God, then everything is permitted.

But living that way didn’t bring me happiness or fulfillment. It mostly made me feel sad and empty.

The other problem was that I had rationally convinced myself that religion was nonsense and that there was no God, but I couldn’t actually make myself feel it.

I think part of the reason atheism didn’t stick was that I had intellectually convinced myself there was no God, but I couldn’t feel it.

I still felt this connection. I felt there was something more than this. I had this spiritual connection that I had experienced for most of my life.

I read the Tao Te Ching and other texts, looking into Taoism. I looked into Judaism and Hinduism. I explored a lot of different traditions.

As part of that journey, I eventually read the Quran. I became convinced that it was a prophetic work. Then I thought, well, if I believe that Muhammad is a prophet and I believe in God, those are the two big things. Maybe Islam would be a good fit for me.

So I looked into Islam more seriously and eventually took the plunge. It was a faith tradition that allowed me to embrace a lot of what I found compelling and attractive about Christianity and other Abrahamic traditions, but without the particular theological complication I had struggled with regarding Jesus and how he understood himself.