Musa al-Gharbi / New York City
I had resolved fairly early on that my plan in life was to become a priest. In preparation, I went to regular Bible studies for years. I was also an altar server in the Catholic Church.
The problem was that after I graduated from high school, when I was getting ready to enter seminary, I started having a crisis of faith. Through my engagement with scripture, I had become convinced that Jesus probably didn’t understand himself to be God.
You had a serious vocational pull?
Oh, yeah. It was very serious. I had been mentored by Father Greg, one of the local priests at St. Andrew’s, and we had been preparing for this for years.
I didn’t have a Plan B. This was the plan.
I talked to the local priests as I was having these theological struggles. We tried to work through them, but I just couldn’t shake the feeling. Eventually, I stepped back from that path.
I basically convinced myself that religion as a whole was bullshit and that there was no God. I really tried to live as if there was no God, in a kind of Dostoevskian way: if there is no God, then everything is permitted.
But living that way didn’t bring me happiness or fulfillment. It mostly made me feel sad and empty.
The other problem was that I had rationally convinced myself that religion was nonsense and that there was no God, but I couldn’t actually make myself feel it.
I think part of the reason atheism didn’t stick was that I had intellectually convinced myself there was no God, but I couldn’t feel it.
I still felt this connection. I felt there was something more than this. I had this spiritual connection that I had experienced for most of my life.
I read the Tao Te Ching and other texts, looking into Taoism. I looked into Judaism and Hinduism. I explored a lot of different traditions.
As part of that journey, I eventually read the Quran. I became convinced that it was a prophetic work. Then I thought, well, if I believe that Muhammad is a prophet and I believe in God, those are the two big things. Maybe Islam would be a good fit for me.
So I looked into Islam more seriously and eventually took the plunge. It was a faith tradition that allowed me to embrace a lot of what I found compelling and attractive about Christianity and other Abrahamic traditions, but without the particular theological complication I had struggled with regarding Jesus and how he understood himself.
-
I’ve really tried to rein myself in when it comes to talking about politics because I’m extraordinarily interested in it. But I want to be fair to you. I’ve reached out specifically for this project to speak about matters of the heart and soul. I feel like the reason I’m reaching out is that not enough people talk about these things. I know you’ve gone through a journey, so if you want to start by describing your own journey.
Sure. I grew up Catholic. My mom and stepdad were both Catholic. My biological father, whom I didn’t know growing up, was actually a chaplain in the Army. I only met him a couple of times when I was young. That’s how he met my mom.
Do you know your father now?
Oh, yeah. Since I moved to the East Coast, we’ve reconnected. We see each other somewhat regularly, and I’ve met a lot of my other siblings. I even met his father, my grandfather, before he passed away. I’d never met him before, but I got to meet him shortly before he died. We’re pretty close now, but growing up, I only saw my father twice.
We were Catholic, but what’s interesting is that my mom is white, my father is Black, and my stepdad is also white. My mom was really concerned about making sure I had an organic connection to Black people and Black culture. She thought the best way to do that was through the Black church.
Growing up, we went to Catholic Mass to receive the Eucharist because it’s a critical sacrament. You have to receive the Eucharist. But after Catholic Mass, we would also go to a Missionary Baptist church, a Black church.
It was great. My mom was kind of the stereotypical white lady in a Black church. Everyone was swaying one way, she was swaying another. People were clapping, and she was walking around. But to her credit, she put herself in that position because she really wanted to make sure we had an organic connection to Black culture.
Was that in Arizona? I lived there briefly and from my experience the black population is not very big. Am I wrong?
Well, Arizona as a whole doesn’t have a huge Black population, but we lived in a military town, Sierra Vista, Arizona, which is next to Fort Huachuca, the Army’s main intelligence base.
Because of the Army, there were a decent number of Black people in my town. But Arizona as a whole doesn’t have a particularly large Black population.
The religious experiences were also very different. In a Catholic Mass, you’re participating in rites that have been passed down more or less in the same form for centuries, sometimes for more than a millennium. It’s a very somber affair. You experience a kind of transcendence, but it’s a particular kind of transcendence.
In a Black Missionary Baptist church, the experience is very different. The music is energetic and rhythmic. The minister is charismatic and passionate, and the service goes on for however long it takes.
With the Catholic Church, you can more or less set your clock by it. You go in, and it’s about an hour. With a Missionary Baptist church, it could be a two-hour service or a three-hour service. The choir gets into it, they keep going with the songs, and if the minister gets carried away, he gets carried away.
After the service, people often bring food. Chicken, potato salad, things like that. You don’t just go to church and leave immediately.
It was a very different experience, but it was interesting to see these two very different traditions.
Did she feel that being Black and Catholic wasn’t enough?
No, I don’t think that was it. There are Black Catholics, of course, although not a huge number. There are even some famous ones, like Henrietta Lacks.
It was more that she wanted to make sure I had a deep connection with other Black people and Black culture. She didn’t feel equipped to provide that herself. At the parish we attended, there weren’t many other Black people.
She also had some aversions to certain aspects of Black pop culture, like rap music. She didn’t want that to be my primary introduction to Black culture.
So for most of my childhood, I went to both churches.
As I was growing up, pretty much everyone in my family was in the Army. My grandfather fought in World War II, Korea, and Vietnam. My mom was in the Army, my stepdad was in the Army, and my biological father was in the Army. He briefly served during Operation Desert Shield. He was based in Turkey, coordinating NATO operations.
Which operation was that?
Desert Shield was the first one. It was before they started aggressively setting up the no-fly zones and things like that. It was the response to Saddam Hussein’s invasion of Kuwait.
A lot of my siblings were in the Army, including my twin brother, who died in Afghanistan. A lot of my cousins were in the military, too.
I was kind of the weirdo because I never really aspired to be a soldier. From a pretty early age, I was convinced I wasn’t going to do that. I was more interested in intellectual and spiritual questions: the meaning of life, the structure and nature of reality, that kind of thing.
I was really into scripture, and I had resolved fairly early on that my plan in life was to become a priest. In preparation, I went to regular Bible studies for years. I was also an altar server in the Catholic Church.
The problem was that after I graduated from high school, when I was getting ready to enter seminary, I started having a crisis of faith. Through my engagement with scripture, I had become convinced that Jesus probably didn’t understand himself to be God.
This is a problem for Catholicism. In the early Church, there were a lot of debates about the nature of Jesus, but they were eventually resolved pretty decisively. There are versions of Christianity that don’t necessarily understand Jesus to be God. In fact, even though the divinity of Jesus is a core tenet of most versions of Christianity, when you look at polling, many Christians don’t necessarily believe it in practice.
But if you’re going to be a priest, it really matters whether you believe this central tenet of Catholic doctrine. If you don’t, it changes the meaning of everything, including the Eucharist, which is one of the most central and serious aspects of the faith.
You had a serious vocational pull?
Oh, yeah. It was very serious. I had been mentored by Father Greg, one of the local priests at St. Andrew’s, and we had been preparing for this for years.
I didn’t have a Plan B. This was the plan.
I talked to the local priests as I was having these theological struggles. We tried to work through them, but I just couldn’t shake the feeling. Eventually, I stepped back from that path.
And then I didn’t really have a vision for my life for a while. Again, I didn’t have a Plan B.
Questioning the divinity of Jesus means questioning a very central premise of Christianity, so your foundations were starting to get shaky.
Yes. In fact, I think I overcorrected. Looking back, I would say I overcorrected quite dramatically.
Instead of thinking, well, maybe Catholicism isn’t right for me, but perhaps there’s another version of Christianity that doesn’t rely so heavily on this particular premise, or maybe I could consider Judaism, which shares the same tradition without the Jesus component, I went in the opposite direction.
I basically convinced myself that religion as a whole was bullshit and that there was no God. I really tried to live as if there was no God, in a kind of Dostoevskian way: if there is no God, then everything is permitted.
How did that manifest? How old were you when that happened?
I was in my late teens, around 19, 20, or 21. It wasn’t a particularly great experience to go through an existential crisis just as I became old enough to drink.
For probably six or seven years, I was in this state of not really knowing what I wanted to do. I was taking classes on and off at the local community college and working various jobs in my hometown of Sierra Vista, Arizona.
While I was taking classes, I started studying philosophy because it was a way of exploring some of the same questions that had haunted me for most of my life: the structure and nature of reality, the meaning of life, and so on, but without necessarily dealing with the God question.
I had a professor at the community college, Mike Jaworski. His own life had taken a somewhat unusual path. He had been a Harvard Society of Fellows scholar and had worked for the World Bank for a while. Then his wife had a kind of mental breakdown, so they decided to live a much simpler life. He had a brother who lived in this Arizona town, so they moved there.
He started teaching at the community college, I think partly because he was bored. But he saw something in me and really tried to nurture it.
Even when I wasn’t taking classes, I would often do private studies with him. He would give me books and then grill me to make sure I had actually read and understood them. We’d have these deep conversations. He even tried teaching me Latin in his downtime.
He invested a lot in me.
I had a problem during this period, though. Actually, I had a few.
One problem was that living in this kind of constraint-free way, I was engaging in a lot of substance abuse. I was drinking heavily and constantly sleeping with different people. At the time, I was pretty charismatic and handsome, so I had plenty of opportunities.
But living that way didn’t bring me happiness or fulfillment. It mostly made me feel sad and empty.
The other problem was that I had rationally convinced myself that religion was nonsense and that there was no God, but I couldn’t actually make myself feel it.
I could try to ignore that feeling, but then I would be a kind of bad-faith atheist, which seemed pretty sad. Or I could say something like, “I’m spiritual but not religious,” or “I’m agnostic.” But I found those positions spiritually and intellectually unfulfilling, too.
So I started looking into other faith traditions. I actively started searching.
I read a lot of primary religious texts from different traditions and did research into different religions. I looked into Buddhism. I had some friends who had converted to Buddhism, and I investigated it for a while, but it wasn’t for me.
I read the Tao Te Ching and other texts, looking into Taoism. I looked into Judaism and Hinduism. I explored a lot of different traditions.
As part of that journey, I eventually read the Quran. I became convinced that it was a prophetic work. Then I thought, well, if I believe that Muhammad is a prophet and I believe in God, those are the two big things. Maybe Islam would be a good fit for me.
So I looked into Islam more seriously and eventually took the plunge.
It was a faith tradition that allowed me to embrace a lot of what I found compelling and attractive about Christianity and other Abrahamic traditions, but without the particular theological complication I had struggled with regarding Jesus and how he understood himself.
It just seemed like a good fit.
That was back in 2008. A little while later, I met my wife, who was also Muslim. We got married and had children.
How old were you when you got married?
I was 25. That’s pretty young by New York standards, but not so much by my wife’s standards. My wife is Lebanese, and for her, by 25, your relatives are starting to wonder whether you’re becoming an old maid.
Also, in the town where I grew up, we were distinguished at Buena High School by our high teenage pregnancy rates.
I think I know where you grew up. I lived in Tucson briefly a long time ago and spent time in Bisbee.
Oh, yes. My wife’s family lives there now.
That’s great. Such a special place.
Yes, it’s a beautiful area. It’s about 20 minutes from my hometown.
When people think of Arizona, they think of the desert. But the area where I grew up has a lot of canyons and much more rainfall. It’s still warm, but it’s not hot like Phoenix.
So that’s the abbreviated version of your journey. After finding Islam, what was it about reading the Quran that spoke to you? You were searching for something, and you were looking at all these different traditions.
For one thing, I was really impressed by it.
One thing that struck me was the rich dialogue between the Quran and the Gospels and the Old Testament, as Christians call it.
I think it’s actually a shame that this relationship isn’t better understood. I wrote a paper about it that I never ended up publishing. There’s this rich interplay between the Quran and these other scriptures, but most Christians aren’t very familiar with the Quran. On the other side, most Muslims don’t really read or know much about the Bible or other Abrahamic traditions.
A lot of this richness gets lost.
There was one person, Leopold Weiss, who changed his name to Muhammad Asad. His son, Talal Asad, is a very famous professor here in the city who does work on secularism and Islam.
Muhammad Asad was a Jewish convert to Islam, and he produced a really wonderful translation and exegesis of the Quran called The Message of the Quran. It includes the Arabic, the English translation, and his explanatory notes.
I think it’s probably the best English translation. He’s also written a lot of interesting material about the connections and interplay between these religious traditions.
That’s one of the things that drew me to Islam. I saw this profound conversation taking place between these holy texts, and I was frustrated that so many people weren’t familiar with it.
I’m want to go back because I’m interested in the moment of conversion. You read the Quran, and it struck a chord. What happened when you read those texts?
I found them very moving. I even wanted to open my book with a verse from fairly early in the Quran, from the second Surah, which is called The Cow in English.
There’s a wonderful passage about people who portray themselves as peacemakers and advocates for justice, while actually creating harm and destruction around them. When they’re challenged about the disastrous consequences of their actions, they insist that they’re peacemakers.
I wanted to open my book with that verse, but Princeton didn’t want a bunch of epigraphs, so it was vetoed.
I think that some Christians would find parallels in the New Testament and the second Surah? The back forth with Pharisees.
Yes, something similar. It’s the kind of dynamic you see in the Gospels, where Jesus is in an aggressive dialogue with certain religious figures.
There’s a whole rich interplay between these traditions.
The Sadducees were woke.
Ha! Yeah. I actually did my formal conversion at the mosque at the University of Arizona in Tucson. There wasn’t a mosque in Sierra Vista at the time.
Had you already started attending the University of Arizona?
Not until later. I started going there around 2010 to 2012. By then, I already considered myself Muslim.
So the text alone was enough to convince you?
The text, along with other research into Islam and the religion more broadly. But it wasn’t a community that initially drew me in.
In fact, community was something I missed during the early years.
One of the things I really appreciated about both the Missionary Baptist Church and the Catholic Church was that religion isn’t fundamentally just a set of beliefs in your head or your heart. It’s also a collection of rituals and traditions passed down through time, carried by people and believers across the world.
It’s a community you’re part of.
I missed that. I could pray by myself, fast, study, and do all those things, but I missed being part of a faith community.
To attend religious services at a mosque, I had to drive about an hour and a half each way. I was working, so it was difficult to go consistently while I was living in Sierra Vista.
For a while, my religious experience was largely solitary, and that was a little difficult in the early stages.
When I started attending the University of Arizona and spending more time in Tucson, I was able to connect with other Muslims. There was a large Muslim population there, and my experience of the religion changed in that respect.
It was also somewhat awkward for my family in the early years. My mom and stepdad weren’t just Catholic; they were also staunch Republicans and came from a military background.
If you had asked my mom to distinguish between the terms Muslim, Arab, and terrorist, she would have been able to distinguish them very clearly. One refers to a religion, one to an ethnicity, and one to something else entirely.
When did you tell your family that you were practicing Islam or had converted?
Pretty much as soon as I had firmly made the decision. I went to the mosque and formally declared my faith in front of witnesses.
That was the formal conversion.
I pretty much told my parents around that time. They weren’t thrilled, although I hadn’t expected them to be particularly interested.
But since then, they’ve seen that having a structure and a renewed sense of purpose in my life has been good for me. I met my wife, they can see that I’m happy and flourishing, and they’ve gradually made peace with it.
I think if they could choose, they’d probably still rather I were Catholic. But they’ve shifted quite a bit.
When I got married, I got married at the mosque and had a religious service. My parents attended, and they were very happy to be there.
My father-in-law, Mel, runs a bodega in Bisbee called Mel’s Bodega. It’s in one of the central buildings in town, and he’s also on the city council.
They get together fairly regularly, even when I’m not there. My mother-in-law and my mom like to go thrift shopping together at Goodwill and places like that.
You mentioned how your family reacted. They weren’t thrilled. Did you feel that their reaction might be a barrier to your conversion? Did you ever think, “I’d like to do this, but…”?
No, I wasn’t particularly worried about it. I had already publicly renounced my faith and was openly living as an atheist.
I was actually pretty militant about it. I was into Sam Harris and things like that. I would get into arguments with people about religion. I had rationally convinced myself that it was all nonsense, and I could have very good arguments challenging other people’s faith.
That’s an extraordinary journey, going from being raised religious, to denouncing the existence of God, and then embracing a very theistic, monotheistic faith.
I think part of the reason atheism didn’t stick was that I had intellectually convinced myself there was no God, but I couldn’t feel it.
I still felt this connection. I felt there was something more than this. I had this spiritual connection that I had experienced for most of my life when participating in religious services.
Ultimately, I ended up in another monotheistic faith tradition because that resonated most with my own feelings and experiences.
I had a sense of connection when I prayed or when I was in church, participating in those occasionally transcendent moments of worship alongside other parishioners.
I felt that what I was connecting to was personal. It had a singular, distinctive quality.
A faith tradition that didn’t include a God, or that was polytheistic or animistic, would have been less satisfying to me. Those traditions didn’t ring true with my own feelings and experiences of religious connection and transcendence.
During my searching period, I was open to different possibilities in principle. But I think that’s part of why some of the other traditions didn’t resonate as strongly. They didn’t connect as well with the experiences I’d had previously.
Could you describe or pinpoint a single moment when Islam clicked for you, or was it more gradual?
I think it was gradual, a grinding of the stones of sorts.
I started reading the Quran and took my time with it. I also looked into different kinds of exegesis.
When I was preparing to become a priest, I hadn’t simply read the Bible. I had studied it critically, looking into its history and the different interpretations. I was sensitive to issues of translation.
For example, in Greek there are two words for “new.” There’s neos, meaning new in the sense of a new car, and kainos, meaning new in the sense of becoming a new person, being transformed.
When you read the English translation, both are simply rendered as “new.” So when Jesus talks about a new heaven and a new earth, or having new bodies, the distinction between those words can be lost. These kinds of nuances are often missed by people who read only in English and aren’t attentive to those distinctions and ambiguities.
I brought that same kind of attention to the Quran. I wasn’t just reading the text. I was also reading it critically and engaging with exegetical material.
It took me a while to get through the Quran, but my conviction grew over time.
I will say, though, that right out of the gate, I thought it was a great text. It’s very punchy and alive.
One of the things I loved about Jesus, when reading the scriptures, was that he was funny. He was inviting, but sometimes mean, too.
Take the parable of the Good Samaritan, for instance.
Most people read it as this kind of feel good story. Jesus asks at the end who acted as the man’s neighbor, and the answer is the one who treated him kindly. Jesus then says, “Go and do the same.”
But there’s a whole other rich subtext in that parable.
The man Jesus is arguing with asks him what the law is. He answers that the law is to love the Lord with all your heart and soul and to treat your neighbor as yourself. He’s referring to Jewish law.
The lawyer is a Jewish lawyer. They’re living under Roman rule, but he’s not asking about Roman law.
Jesus says, essentially, “Great, go do that.”
But the lawyer asks, “Who is my neighbor?” He’s trying to justify himself.
The reason he asks this is that Judaism, like many other faith traditions, has rules about how you treat your fellow co-religionists. You’re generally held to a higher standard in how you treat members of your own religious community than people outside it.
So the lawyer is testing Jesus. He’s trying to see whether Jesus will say something that contradicts the Old Testament.
Jesus responds with the parable.
The details are important. The fact that the man is a traveler matters because, in the Old Testament, angels sometimes appear in the guise of travelers to test people. The story of Lot in Sodom and Gomorrah is one example.
There’s a strong injunction to take particular care of travelers, even more than ordinary people in your community. So the fact that this traveler is ignored is already a significant problem.
Then the people who walk past him include a Levite. The Levites were one of the tribes of Israel, responsible for maintaining religious rituals. They were forbidden from engaging in other forms of work and were supported through the tithe. Jewish people gave a significant portion of their income, traditionally about 10 percent, to support those responsible for maintaining religious traditions.
So you have someone whose entire livelihood and purpose in life is to uphold religious traditions, and he walks past this traveler.
Then there’s a priest who does the same thing.
Finally, a Samaritan comes along and helps him.
Most people don’t really know who the Samaritans were. They were an ethno-religious group connected to the Jewish people. They were a kind of Jewish offshoot who had remained in the region while other Jews were expelled and dispersed during the periods of exile described in the Old Testament.
They believed that many other Jews were practicing a corrupted form of Judaism, that their beliefs had been compromised during their time in exile.
So they understood mainstream Jews as having lost their way in some important sense.
To have a priest and a Levite ignore this traveler, and then have a Samaritan help him, is an incendiary metaphor. Jesus is essentially saying, “Maybe the Samaritans are right about us. Maybe we’ve lost our way.”
It’s a very biting story. Every part of it is biting, including the specific people who ignore the traveler.
You get the general idea that we’re united more by how we treat one another than by blood or religious affiliation. Most people understand that basic message.
But you miss the richness of the story, and you miss the personality of Jesus.
This wasn’t some kind of feel good, kumbaya story. It was edgy and provocative. It was intended to provoke and offend the person who had asked him the question.
One of the things I loved about reading the Gospels was that Jesus had a personality. He was funny, provocative, and sometimes quite sharp.
And likewise, when you read the Quran, you get a sense of a distinct personality in the text. It’s a text that has a personality of its own.
How do you view your Catholicism now that you’re no longer practicing it and have embraced another faith?
I still have a great deal of respect for Catholicism and for Catholics in general.
One of the things I think is really beautiful about Catholicism, especially compared with other versions of Christianity, is that it’s one of the earliest surviving continuous expressions of the Christian faith.
There are rites, traditions, and theological arguments that have persisted over millennia. It’s a faith tradition, a body of beliefs, canons, and practices that people have been discussing and debating for thousands of years.
There’s something beautiful and transcendent about participating in those rituals and being part of a faith community like that.
I like Pope Francis a lot. I was less of a fan of his predecessor, Cardinal Ratzinger, although I can’t remember his papal name for the life of me.
Benedict?
Yes, Benedict XVI.
Part of the reason was that he took over the Church after the death of John Paul II, at a time when it was trying to navigate the sexual abuse scandal. That was a difficult time for anyone to be pope.
But Ratzinger had also been a member of the Nazi military during his youth. He served as an anti-aircraft gunner during World War II.
His explanation for that, to my mind, was unacceptable. He essentially said he was young, that he had been swept up in it, and that he didn’t have a choice.
But you were a gunner. You were actively aiming and shooting at planes, trying to hit them. Come on.
It’s not as though you were a passive participant or someone whose involvement was purely formal. There were people who were members of the Ba’ath Party under Saddam Hussein who didn’t necessarily agree with the party or do anything particularly significant. They might have been managing traffic or something like that, but they were formally members.
That wasn’t the situation here. He was actively participating.
Rather than really reckoning with that, and talking about the transformative power of faith, grace, sincere penance, and personal responsibility, there were resources available within Catholicism and Christianity to address the depravity of the regime he had been part of.
But instead, he seemed to say, essentially, “Hitler was bad, but I didn’t have a choice. My hands are clean.”
I found that very difficult to accept.
Fortunately, by that point I wasn’t really a Catholic, so his being pope wasn’t particularly relevant to me theologically. But I was baffled by the choice.
He was also a very thoughtful person who made some interesting theological contributions. I can understand how he ended up becoming pope, but I still think he was the wrong choice.
There’s a lot of discussion among Catholics in America right now about this tension within Catholicism. I feel like many non-Catholics love Francis, while a lot of Catholics are frustrated with him.
You can see this tension partly because Francis has been so outspoken about inequality, resisting war, and condemning violence. He also emphasizes compassion toward gay and transgender people.
He believes that marriage is a sacrament between a man and a woman, which remains the doctrine of the Catholic Church. But he has also encouraged states to consider civil unions for gay people because he thinks it’s better for people to be in committed, monogamous relationships that are legally protected.
These positions have frustrated many conservatives in the United States. Francis cares about the poor and the sick, and he doesn’t support war. You can see this tension even within the Republican Party.
I remember John Boehner crying when Pope Francis visited Congress.
Yes. I actually wrote an essay for Salon about that back in 2015.
Pope Francis came to visit, and John Boehner, who was Speaker of the House, was crying throughout much of the event.
Part of it was that he was in the presence of the Pope, whom Catholics understand to be God’s representative on Earth. But I think he was also aware that many of the things Francis was talking about and condemning were positions that his own party stood on the other side of.
You could see him wrestling with that tension. Eventually, he left politics shortly afterward.
That tension Boehner seemed to be feeling at that moment is something you see among a lot of Catholics, especially the very online Catholics on Twitter. Many of them are deeply frustrated with Pope Francis.
I know you have a number of Catholic friends. You mentioned someone earlier.
Yes. I have a lot of Catholic friends, including Sohrab, who does a lot of public-facing work.
Tell me more about him and your friendship.
Sohrab Ahmari, he’s currently a writer for The New Statesman. He’s also a co-founder of Compact Magazine, although he has since stepped away from that.
He’s of Iranian background. He grew up Muslim and converted to Catholicism, so he has had almost the opposite religious journey from me.
He lives here in the city. We were Internet friends for a while, then we met, and now we’re actual friends.
He’s written for First Things and other publications.
Anyway, I have a lot of friends and colleagues who are Catholic. Many are conservative Catholics, but some are more progressive.
For the more progressive Catholics, Francis has been a breath of fresh air. He’s been the pope they’ve been waiting for.
Even John Paul II, during his papacy, consistently advocated for peace and expressed concern for the poor. But because of his upbringing and the geopolitical environment in which he operated, he was also very anti-communist.
A lot of communist regimes were aggressively anti-religious, including particularly anti-Catholic, so it makes sense that the Pope would oppose a regime that was hostile to religion.
But at the same time, some of that anti-communist advocacy veered into, or provided intellectual support for, people who simply hated the political left in general.
So John Paul II could easily be characterized as being anti-left, even though his own words consistently expressed concern for the poor.
For a lot of more left-leaning Catholics, Francis has been a breath of fresh air.
Of course, many left-leaning people also left the Catholic Church during the sexual abuse scandal. So the number of left-leaning people who remain Catholic is relatively small.
I realized after emailing you that it was Ramadan and I felt badly for not considering that and waited for the holiday to pass before picking up the correspondence again. What does your religious practice look like on a day-to-day basis or over the course of the year?
We just finished Ramadan, and this year was interesting because it took place during my book tour. Fasting was quite a challenge.
I did when I could. The Quran is very emphatic that the purpose of religion should be to enrich and enhance your life, not become a burden. You’re not supposed to try to stunt yourself or make things unnecessarily difficult.
For example, if you’re menstruating, pregnant, or ill, you’re not only exempt from fasting, you’re actually discouraged from doing it. The same applies to travelers. If you’re going on a long and arduous journey, you’re not supposed to fast.
So if I was traveling all day, for example, flying to California, I wouldn’t fast. The whole process of getting from Long Island to New York, then flying across the country, arriving at an unusual time, and dealing with all the logistics makes it difficult.
You can’t really pray on an airplane in the same way, either.
But if I was staying somewhere for a few days, I would try to fast.
I tried to manage it that way, although I couldn’t fast as consistently as I would have liked because of the book tour.
One nice thing about Ramadan is that the purpose of fasting is to draw your mind toward higher things and remind you how unnecessary many of the things we take for granted really are.
Prayer serves a similar purpose. One of the great things about praying multiple times a day is that you have these moments when you step away from whatever you’re doing. You reorient yourself and recalibrate toward something more transcendent than the daily grind of tweeting your latest article or whatever else you’re doing.
Ramadan is wonderful for that reason, too.
Throughout the day, you’re not eating or drinking. You’re also not supposed to engage in anger or violence, or in lustful behavior or sexual activity, even with your spouse.
I can imagine that presents some challenges.
It actually became a logistical challenge for us.
My wife and I often take advantage of the daytime, when the kids are at school, because we both have flexible schedules. That’s when we enjoy our time together, especially since we’re often tired late at night after finishing work.
I know what you mean. My wife and I give each other a high five on Monday mornings. We call it “TGI Monday”.
Exactly. So we had to figure out some logistics during Ramadan, but we managed.
The kids really get into fasting, too. They’re very excited about Ramadan.
My son is 13 and my daughter is 10. In previous years, they did partial fasts. They would fast while they were at school and then break their fast when they came home. It’s difficult for young kids, especially when they have physical education and other activities.
This year, my son tried to do a full fast.
When you’re Jewish or Catholic, you go through certain milestones, like confirmation. Is there something similar in Islam? A ceremony or a coming-of-age ritual?
There’s no adult equivalent that we’ve participated in. We haven’t done anything like that.
But it’s another thing I appreciate about both of those faith traditions: the idea of actively choosing your faith and making a conscious decision to opt into it. I think that’s a nice ritual.
At the end of Ramadan, there’s Eid. It’s a couple of days of celebration, and especially for children, you usually get new clothes and things like that, new shoes. They’re very excited about that, too.
This has been great. I want to keep the conversation going, but we have to leave the studio. I’m supposed to be out there in about eight minutes. Thank you so much.