Rav Tiferet Berenbaum / Brookline, MA
When I decided that Judaism was really the path that I wanted to use to explore this relationship with God, ritual and community, because that's what it came down to. I told my mom, I said, mommy, I think, I think I'm Jewish. And my mom said, we always knew you were a Jew.
My mother and I struggled in the beginning because she felt that my becoming Jewish was really saying, “I don’t want to be Black” or “I want to be white.”
I certainly didn’t understand it that way. At the time, it wasn’t about race for me. It was about this relationship with God and finding a community where I could express it. I understand why it appeared that way, though, because neither my mother nor I knew any Jews of color.
I recognize my position as someone coming into this tradition and what that means. For me, it was in my soul. I’ve always been Jewish, but I didn’t always have the language for it.
And so, like, to me, that really resonates. Like, I'm a Jew because of my Blackness as well. And those two things go together. And in America, Jewishness and whiteness are so intertwined. And for me, that's, something I struggle with a lot. How do we disentangle these two things? How do you maintain the meaning of an identity that is an oppressed identity, a marginalized identity, and still have access to the privileges of the majority of the oppressing identities?
-
So I think the story really started here in Brookline. I grew up here, and I remember going to the supermarket and seeing a Chabad woman there. I didn’t know what Chabad was at all. I grew up Southern Baptist, and this woman was handing out Shabbat candles. She asked me, “Do you light Shabbat candles?”
I was eight or nine at the time, so I really liked free things. I was like, sure.
So she gave me these Shabbat candles, and I was very happy. I took them home, and inside there was a little pamphlet about what Shabbat is, how we light candles, and so on. That was my first introduction to the idea of having a ritual practice for the Sabbath.
My family weren’t regular churchgoers, which I now understand as a parent with a young child. Sometimes life doesn’t work out that way. I didn’t really have an idea of what Sunday was, but there was no ritual element to it for us. So all of a sudden, having a ritual element was new and exciting for me.
I took those candles and put them out, but I didn’t light them because my mother was terrified of having fire in the house. That was the root of my idea of having a meaningful Sabbath. From there, Saturday grew into my Sabbath day. I didn’t do homework on Saturdays, and I didn’t make plans on Saturdays. Sunday became my real workday, my day to get ready for the week.
When I was about two years older, I was in Catholic school over here, and we had a Seder at school. I thought, “Oh, this is fascinating. I love this ritual about freedom.” As a Black American, I had heard the narratives of our enslaved ancestors.
That wasn’t something my parents talked about very much. It wasn’t really part of my childhood. So having a ritual around enslavement and freedom was so exciting to me.
Those experiences, along with the Shabbat candles, stayed with me. I kept them in my consciousness, but I was still young. I was in fifth grade, and I didn’t really have the language for it or even the ability to act on it.
When I was in sixth grade, I had my first real prayer experience, or I should say, my first experience with God through earnest prayer. It was like a conversation. I was dealing with middle school drama at the time, and I remember falling down and praying. God answered my prayers, and I thought, “Oh, wow, that’s amazing. This prayer thing works.”
From there, it evolved into figuring out what this relationship with God was. I continued that conversation with God throughout high school.
When I was in eighth grade, I moved to another school that had a large Jewish population. I went to my first bat mitzvah, and that was a game changer for me.
I went to the service and sat with my friends in the back. I got annoyed with them for talking because I came from a Southern Baptist background, where no one talks during the church service. But all my friends were chatting.
The fact that we were even allowed to sit together was like, whoa.
I’ll never forget this. It was at Temple Emeth in Chestnut Hill. The ark opened, the Torah came out, and everyone stood up. I thought, “This is amazing.” I remember wanting all of it: the pomp, the circumstance, the people wearing tallitot. This ritual was so rich.
A classmate said, “No, you can’t put on a tallit. That’s only for Jews.” I was crushed. I thought, “What?” So in that moment, I realized that I really wanted to be part of this, but there was a doorway I couldn’t pass through.
As I moved through high school, my spirituality continued to develop. I was the spiritual one among my friends. None of them are surprised that I’m a rabbi. I was the spiritual one, even though I didn’t go to church and didn’t have a religious community.
I just had this strong connection with God and faith.
In college, I had Jewish friends, and I learned a little about Judaism, mostly cultural Judaism. A good friend of mine, who also comes to this shul, went to Monday night schul because he was in high school. I’d ride with him and learn a little about his Jewish teen program.
That was about it. We’d have conversations about Judaism and Israel, but there wasn’t any more participation on my part until my freshman year of college.
My boyfriend at the time was Jewish, and his father died. We went to Hillel to say Kaddish.
At the time, I’d been looking for a spiritual community. It was my freshman year of college, and I was an adult now. I wanted somewhere to go. My parents weren’t going to take me to church, so I wanted to find a place for myself.
I went to church with my Catholic friend, but I definitely didn’t want that. I discovered an American Baptist church near my college. I went to Tufts in Medford, and the church was nearby.
I walked in and didn’t know there were white Baptists. It was a white Baptist church.
The woman there was very guarded. She asked, “Can I help you? Why are you here?”
I said, “No reason,” and turned around and walked right back out.
That felt like a door closing in my face. I didn’t want to do the Catholic thing, either. So I thought, “Where are my people?”
Then I went to say Kaddish. It was Friday night, and there was this quiet stillness and a kind of welcoming atmosphere. I thought, “Oh, this is what I’ve been looking for.”
I had a checklist in my mind of what I wanted. The Sabbath being on Saturday was one of those things. Throughout high school, I’d always said, “Well, if there were a church that met on Saturday, I’d go.” Or even at night. So I thought, “Oh, it’s Friday night. This is kind of my speed.”
Then, during that first service, we got to the Amidah. There was silence and time to commune with God as we understand God individually. I thought, “This is amazing.”
I loved going to church because the music was great, but there was never any time to just be quietly with God. That’s what I was looking for. That was my doorway in: having a one-to-one conversation with God. I thought, “Wow, I can just do that.”
Then we got to the parsha, the Parshat HaShavua, and I thought, “Wait, you all are reading the book in order, from beginning to end? That’s what I’ve been looking for.”
When you go to church, there’s a passage from here and another from somewhere else. I didn’t know the basic story, so I couldn’t really participate in it.
I’d taken it upon myself to try to read through the Bible in order, from beginning to end. Now I was seeing a community doing the things I was already doing and wanted to do. I thought, “This must be where I belong.”
I found a book called Choosing a Jewish Life by Anita Diamant, who’s a local author. I was in college, so reading and doing homework came easily to me. I read that book in one night. I just inhaled it.
My best friend gave me another book about Jewish living, and I read that one, too. I really settled on the idea that I thought my soul was Jewish, and that this was what I needed to realize my relationship with God.
I don’t think my relationship with God ever changed. Now I had a language and a ritual life I could use to express it.
Very early on, I wasn’t in the Jesus camp. Because I’d already developed this relationship with God, when Jesus came into the picture, I thought, “But I already have a relationship with God. I don’t need that.”
That annoyed my parents and many Christians I spoke with, particularly fundamentalist Christians, rather than the more understanding ones.
So I read these books and decided that this was the life path I wanted to pursue.
But it’s also a joy and an honor to be able to fulfill the mitzvah of Kibbud Av Va’em, honoring our parents. There’s a tradition that we’re supposed to do all the mitzvot, but that we can take one mitzvah and really make it our own. I feel like honoring our parents is the mitzvah I’ve really made my own.
It’s one of the Ten Commandments. When I was a child and didn’t want to do something or wasn’t listening, my mother would say, “Honor your mother and your father, for the days will be…” It was like, oh, no!
My mom really instilled the fear of God in me. I got the fear part, and I think my prayer life helped me discover the love aspect of it.
My parents both instilled so much spirituality and faith in me. I’m very grateful for that foundational upbringing because I don’t know how I would exist without that foundation of faith in my life.
Did your parents grow up in Massachusetts?
No, they’re from New Jersey, both of them. They grew up very much in the church. My grandmother founded a church, so her kids obviously had to go all the time. It’s like my kid lives in this building, you know?
My aunt is still very involved in the church. That’s her church. My father grew up in the church, too. They were active participants. They were there all the time, Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday. They sang, and they met at church.
Their lives had a very strong spiritual foundation, which they passed on to me, even without the ritual part.
So, going back to the story, when I decided that Judaism was the path I wanted to use to explore my relationship with God, ritual, and community, I told my mom, “Mommy, I think I’m Jewish.”
My mom said, “We always knew you were a Jew.”
Did she explain why?
No, she didn’t explain why. It’s a shame because now I can’t really… Well, I could ask her. I haven’t asked her.
I think it might have been because I had a love of detailed text study.
I remember that same year, when I was in sixth grade and starting to get into God, I came downstairs on Christmas morning. I’m an only child, so the living room was filled with gifts, and my parents were so happy. They said, “Open your gifts!”
But before that, I’d prepared a sermon. I gave a sermon about whether this was really what Jesus wanted. It was very much in the vein of the prophet Isaiah, now that I think about it. I was asking, “Is this really what Jesus wants? What is our life supposed to be?”
My mother was like, “Oh my God, just open your gifts!”
So there’s that.
I’d always had questions, and I still don’t do anything without questioning it. That’s so central to Judaism in a wonderful, exploratory way. Outside of Judaism, not so much. It’s often seen as being contrary.
So that’s how I fell into Judaism and started going to a synagogue.
It was interesting because the only Jews I knew were white, and that became a point of contention in my household.
I grew up here in Brookline and went to private school here. There were still quotas. We had four Black girls and one Black guy in every class. That was it. I don’t know if it was a written quota, but we could look around and count.
What was that related to?
Friends. All the Jewish people you met were white.
Oh, yeah, it’s true. All the people of color I met were not Jewish.
That was a challenge. My mother and I struggled in the beginning because she felt that my becoming Jewish was really saying, “I don’t want to be Black” or “I want to be white.”
I certainly didn’t understand it that way. At the time, it wasn’t about race for me. It was about this relationship with God and finding a community where I could express it.
I understand why it appeared that way, though, because neither my mother nor I knew any Jews of color.
When I looked for a synagogue to attend, you couldn’t just call a synagogue and ask about the diversity of its congregation the way you can now. In the year 2000, I couldn’t just pick up the phone and say, “Hey, do you have Black people in your shul?”
I was nervous about how I would find a community. But again, I followed the signs. I talked it over with God, and there happened to be an open house at a synagogue. I saw a poster at the library, so I thought, “Okay, I’ll go try this place.”
It was in Milton, close to Mattapan.
And you’d made a decision then to seek out Judaism and possibly convert?
Yeah, but I knew I needed community. You can be Jewish on your own, but you really can’t, right?
I went to this synagogue and met with the rabbi, who was absolutely wonderful. She encouraged me to come to services, and I did.
There was one other Black person, so I thought, “Okay, one is better than none.” I felt comfortable, and everyone was so kind and welcoming. I felt at home, and it was really good in a way I hadn’t experienced in other places, certainly not at church.
I always felt like a guest at church. That was probably partly because we didn’t go frequently, so I kind of was a guest. No one got to know my family, or the people who knew my family knew them from way back but didn’t know me.
I really came to feel at home at that synagogue.
The rabbi and I had become close because, as part of the conversion process, we had lots of in-depth conversations about Jewish living and all sorts of things. She lived here in Brookline and would often give me a ride home from shul.
One time, she said, “I want to bring you to the synagogue I go to when I’m not working.”
I was really excited. She brought me here to TBZ, and it was amazing.
This congregation has always been… I don’t know the right term. Non-denominational? Since the late 1990s, when Rav Moshe Waldoks came. Before that, it was Conservative, and it was a dying shul, as most Conservative shuls were at the time.
Then Rav Moshe came with his Rav Moshe magic. He brought a kind of Judaism infused with Eastern wisdom and Hasidic tradition. We became an unorthodox shul, one where the doors were open to people who were seeking.
You mentioned early on, when you first encountered Judaism at the bat mitzvah, that you felt you might have a Jewish soul. You also said that you felt at home. When I’ve spoken to other people who, as adults, have found their way to a religious community, they often use similar language, like finding home. I think that’s interesting. I don’t want to put those words in your mouth, but I wondered whether you’d describe it that way.
Yeah. There are a lot of metaphors I like to think about.
Along with finding home, there’s not belonging, or wandering from where you came. Where do I belong?
That’s so deeply foundational to Judaism. Abraham was a wanderer, you know, Abraham hunting for freedom from wherever he came from. And there’s wandering in the wilderness. The Torah ends without us landing anywhere. We’re still a wandering people, and we’ve been kicked out and forced to wander from here to there.
That sense of spiritual homelessness resonated with me, too. And I do feel so at home.
One of the metaphors I think about is becoming an American. You come to this country from wherever you are. You couldn’t stay there for whatever reason, and now you’re here. You want to be here. There are tests you have to take.
I look at it as something very similar because one thing I noticed during my conversion process, and afterward, was that I encountered plenty of Jewish people who didn’t really care about Jewishness or Judaism. They were just Jews, you know? Except for my friend Josh, who was very actively Jewish.
Meanwhile, here I was, taking classes and doing all these things to discover what Judaism was and to make meaning of it for myself.
A year or two after I’d officially converted, I met a woman who was Jewish. I said, “Oh, you’re Jewish! That’s great. It’s Tisha B’Av. How are you commemorating it?”
She said, “What are you talking about?”
I just assumed she would know what I was talking about.
I think about people who immigrate to this country and have to learn its history and take a citizenship test. I couldn’t pass the citizenship test, even though I’m American. I just happen to be American. I don’t think about what being American means to me.
I recognize my position as someone coming into this tradition and what that means. For me, it was in my soul. I’ve always been Jewish, but I didn’t always have the language for it.
And I’m coming into a community that may have a very different experience: “We’ve always been Jewish. This is just what we do.”
That’s very interesting. What’s it like to be a chosen Jew in a community where people didn’t necessarily choose it?
Yeah, which is different from here at TBZ, because TBZ is made up of seekers, people who are choosing this spiritual path.
Even now, we have a lot of people who come to TBZ and aren’t Jewish but convert through the synagogue. Our senior rabbi, Rav Claudia, has to say, “You can’t convert to TBZ. You convert to Judaism.”
Which I knew, of course, but living here and coming to TBZ, I was part of the community throughout rabbinical school. I spent many years of my life here. It wasn’t until I left and lived in Wisconsin that I realized Judaism has a different flavor. It can be very different.
How did you end up in divinity school?
That started even before my conversion. This might tap into what my mother saw in me. Our parents see things in us as children.
When I was seven, I put on my dad’s bathrobe, lined up all my stuffed animals, flipped over my table to turn it into a bimah, and gave a sermon to my stuffed animals about God and how we have to love God. I was a little sermonizer. I was a baby pastor forever.
So giving sermons later on probably wasn’t so strange to my parents if they’d been watching that progression.
When I started meeting with Rabbi Crystal, the rabbi at the shul in Milton, we talked a lot. I had so many questions and thoughts because I’d been doing so much reading on my own.
She said, “If you’re asking these kinds of questions, maybe you should go to rabbinical school.”
I thought, “Okay.” I had no idea what that meant or how much it cost.
That was the first push.
Then, in my conversion classes, I felt like they were too basic because I’d already had all those meetings with the rabbi.
I went to the rabbi who still teaches those classes, which is great because I just sat on a beit din with her the other day. It was like, “Oh my gosh, this is full circle.”
I asked her, “Can I teach these classes?”
Mind you, I hadn’t even officially converted yet, but I wanted to teach them.
She said, “You have to be a rabbi to teach these classes.”
I thought, “Well, I guess I have to go become a rabbi. This is what I have to do. This is my life path.”
I was 19, and I thought, “All right, this is my life path.”
I was in college at the time and trying to figure out my major. I was really interested in psychology, and I’d just converted. So I started taking classes in Jewish subjects and found them absolutely fascinating.
I took classes in Yiddish theater, Jews on film, Ladino, Sephardic culture, Yiddish culture, and Talmud. All of these things were fantastic.
I ended up with a second major in Jewish studies simply because I’d done all that coursework.
Psychology and Jewish studies?
Yeah. I wasn’t intending to major in Jewish studies. I was just studying things I liked. But I did all the coursework, took Hebrew, and did everything.
I knew I wasn’t quite ready for rabbinical school after graduating, so I was planning to go into clinical psychology.
I don’t know if it’s still like this, but at the time, clinical psychology was one of those professions where you needed experience to get experience. I didn’t have any experience.
Rabbi Tammy, Rabbi Crystal, also told me I had to take my passion for Jewish learning and teach Hebrew school. She said, “That’s something you have to do. That avenue needs your energy.”
So I applied to a non-denominational Jewish after-school education program in Cambridge that wasn’t connected to a synagogue.
The woman called me back about ten minutes later, and I had a job.
That was fantastic because I had all this Jewish learning, but I had no idea what it was like to be a Jewish child.
It was so much fun. I was about a lesson ahead of the kids, and I got to co-create Jewish learning experiences with them.
I had a co-teacher, which was fantastic. All the classes were team-taught. We got to play with Judaism and create spaces for discovery while I was discovering things myself.
Preparing for the kids, I would think, “Oh my, you know what? This is amazing.”
It was an amazing experience, and I carry it with me. We usually have our after-school Jewish education program on Wednesdays, and that’s the energy I bring from day one: “Oh my God, this is the most amazing thing!”
I bring that energy every Wednesday. “You guys, this is so awesome. I don’t think you quite understand.”
After that, I spent two years at Kesher, which was fantastic. Every year had a theme. One year might focus on Jewish holidays, another on Jewish values, and another on Jewish history.
I was getting more of the learning I wanted, which was fantastic.
Then I applied to rabbinical school. Rabbi Tammy had told me that if these were the kinds of questions I wanted to explore, rabbinical school was the place to do it. It was amazing.
I went to Hebrew College, which keeps moving farther and farther out now.
Were there any other converts among your classmates?
Among my classmates? No, I don’t think so. There were others in the school, but not among my classmates.
There weren’t other Jews of color, either, which was interesting.
There was another person who was about my skin tone, maybe even a little darker, but he didn’t consider himself a Jew of color. That wasn’t his lived experience.
There were certainly Jews from Latin America who didn’t consider themselves Jews of color, either. That wasn’t their lived experience.
I was the only person of color I encountered much of the time, whether I was going to school in Newton or living here in Brookline, apart from my parents.
Your parents converted as well?
No, no, no. I just mean they were the other people of color I’d see.
My mom is still a Southern Baptist. My father was still a Southern Baptist when he died.
I had another question about your friends and family and how they reacted to your conversion. I know how your mom reacted.
My dad took a little longer to come around. He just didn’t understand. He didn’t talk about it much until he discovered he could tell people about it. Then it became a totally different story.
He could say, “My daughter’s in rabbinical school,” and his clients would respond, “Oh my gosh, that’s amazing!”
It was a very different thing.
You mentioned that perhaps they viewed it as a betrayal of your…
Blackness, yeah.
That was so interesting because I wasn’t raised in a household where there was a celebration of the beauty of Blackness and Black culture. I don’t want to say we weren’t raised Black, but we didn’t talk about those things.
In fact, it was much the opposite. My parents would say disparaging things.
I’d hear those things and try to figure out what to do with them. It didn’t make sense to me. How can you say that about Black women when you are a Black woman, or about Black men when you are a Black man?
That was a challenge. But then, at the same time, to say that I didn’t want to be Black was confusing. It was like, “Well, it seems like you don’t want to be Black, either.”
So, yeah, it was never set up that way.
This is way off topic, but have you found an identity in Judaism where being Black and Jewish work together? You said that wasn’t part of your upbringing.
Yeah. A really rich metaphor for me is Moses. Moshe Rabbeinu. I’m not trying to say I’m a great human being by any means, but I think about Moses a lot.
He grew up in the Egyptian palace. He had no idea he was a Hebrew. He grew up with all this privilege, over there, and as soon as he went out into the world, he thought, “Whoa, what is this injustice? What’s happening?”
Then he really stepped into his purpose: “These are my people.”
I felt very much as though that was how my life unfolded.
I grew up here in Brookline, in a world that was very cut off from the Black experience, from what it meant to live a Black life and make meaning of that identity.
I wasn’t allowed to go into the inner city. I went there once in high school, and I actually wrote my college entrance essay about it because it was such a big thing in my life to cross a border my whole family had established, a border I was never supposed to cross.
Then I went to live in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Milwaukee was about 49 percent Black, and discovering what it meant to be Black there was a very interesting experience.
That helped me realize how much I’d taken for granted my whole life. I don’t mean that my experiences here weren’t real or that they were equivalent to what I experienced there. There was a lot of poverty in the areas I was in, and I’d never experienced that here. I saw a lot of injustice, too, and things I hadn’t even thought about when I was growing up here.
Getting away from home and living in a place with a much larger Black population helped me start making sense of my identity as a Black Jewish person.
Again, it came back to those initial things that had been important to me, like the Seder and the idea that Judaism is a liberatory tradition.
The foundation of our belief is that we were slaves to Pharaoh, that we stood up for that, and that God came and got us.
That really resonates with me. I’m a Jew because of my Blackness as well. Those two things go together.
In America, Jewishness and whiteness are so intertwined. I just don’t understand that, and it’s something I struggle with a lot. How do we disentangle those two things?
How do you maintain the meaning of an identity that is oppressed and marginalized while still having access to the privileges of the majority, the identities associated with those who are doing the oppressing? What does that look like? How does it manifest in other people?
That’s what I’m trying to study in school right now.
I feel a huge tension there, and I don’t think it’s explored because race makes people uncomfortable. Race doesn’t have to be challenging, but people don’t want to talk about it.
I don’t think conversations about race and racialization are happening in Jewish institutions.
They were happening after 2020, when everybody was talking about race, racialization, and all these things. But now we’re not talking about that. I feel that. I feel how that conversation has been put down, especially since October 7, when the war broke out.
I got an email about this just last night. Groups of Black Americans are standing in solidarity with Palestinians, and that creates another division. As a Black Jewish person, where does that leave me? Do I have to be in this camp or that camp? Where’s the space in between for conversations?
It’s very hard to have those conversations when everyone’s hurting and in pain, and no one feels seen. It’s complicated.
Are you in touch with other Black rabbis and Black Jewish people?
I’m starting to build those connections, which I’m really excited about. I’ve been in touch a little with Rabbi Lawson, I think.
I was going to say there’s no “Let’s all just get together as Black rabbis,” but sometimes there are. Sometimes we’re like, “All right, we all just need to bring it in,” you know?
That happened a lot in 2020, which was great.
I was wondering whether this discussion, this debate, is happening.
Not that I’m a part of. I think what’s happening, and what I am part of, is the “so what,” right?
I’m now part of Amud, a rabbinical school for Jews of color. We’re building Torah for Jews of color, by Jews of color.
We’ve spent so much time asking how we get white people, or Jews who are racialized as white, to do this or that. But we can also create and build for ourselves, centering our experiences and our needs.
That feels like a much more positive and fruitful experience for me, and I’m thrilled to be part of it.
I was just on a call about this last night. We’re building community now. I’m one of the first ambassadors for building this community here in the Boston area.
There were two other rabbis and a rabbinical student on the call last night, all Jews of color, building small communities in different cities. They’re small at the moment because we’re just getting started, but we’re trying to grow Torah for Jews of color, by Jews of color, for ourselves, rather than in response to someone else.
There was a lot of discussion at the time about who is a Jew and who isn’t. I feel like we’re moving past that and into a place where we’re saying, “We are people of color, and Torah is for us. We’re creating a bigger tent for how we do Judaism.”
That feels really good and positive.
You’ve been so gracious and talked about so many of the things I wanted to discuss. One thing I’m curious about is how you now view the religion you grew up with, the religion of your parents and grandparents. Your grandmother founded a church and all of that. How do you view that faith now?
The bulk of what I know about Christianity, I learned in rabbinical school. I’ve approached it through a foundation of deep Torah learning, so I have many more questions now, and I get answers to them.
I’m not asking questions without a deep Torah foundation.
Sometimes I get frustrated because I think about the person of Jesus. I don’t want to say the character of Jesus because that might sound like I’m putting him down, but I think about Jesus as a religious Jew.
To me, obviously, if this is the person you’re following, the thing to do is to follow in his footsteps.
When I think about that, I feel like I’ve passed that test. Jesus was a very learned Jewish person. He was a rabbi. He was preaching the spirit of the law while holding it together with the letter of the law.
I think that’s what we get here at TBZ. Jesus would totally come to this shul, you know? It’s traditional, but it also embraces the spirit of the law.
So I always wonder, how do you do this without Torah? Without the foundation of it all?
I understand the Christian interpretation, that Paul, who used to be Saul, came along and understood Jesus as fulfilling certain prophecies. But I think that’s based on a misunderstanding of what it means to fulfill them.
I argue with it in my head all the time. It doesn’t make sense to me, but that’s why I’m Jewish, right? And I feel like that’s okay.
I don’t put people down because I understand that Christianity is meaningful to them. At the end of the day, if you have something meaningful that inspires you to be a good person, help other people, and tread lightly on this earth, great. Fantastic.
But in terms of the practicality, I don’t understand how you can do it without Torah, Shabbat, Pesach, and all these underlying things that give meaning to Jesus’s life and the things he said. It just doesn’t make sense to me.
Okay, putting all the theological and learned things aside, if you look just at the cultural aspects, is there anything you miss?
Absolutely. I just had this conversation with my good friend on Saturday night. This might be my next project. I wish there were a non-denominational gathering, something that wasn’t Christian, a Jesus-free gathering of Black people with gospel music that didn’t mention Jesus.
A place where we could have some quiet and connect to God as we understand God, without having to…
I want the spirit and excitement of a gospel choir, but also the contemplative quietness.
I was talking with my friend about this because her family also founded a church. The church is just up the street from her house, but she doesn’t go because it doesn’t feel like home or welcoming to her. It doesn’t speak to her spirituality or how she understands God.
I asked, “Can we just create something like this? Where we have fun gospel music and then maybe eat together?”
I miss that. I have a Spotify playlist of gospel music that doesn’t mention Jesus, and I rock out to it on my way to places.
I also wish I had a place where I could talk about God and how God has worked in my life, because that’s such a big part of the experience of going to a Black church. You can stand up and talk about it.
I wish I had a place to do that. I can talk about it with people in other settings, but it’s not the same.
That’s what attracted me to Hasidic Judaism. I feel like Hasidim are the Baptists of the Jews, you know? That’s why I study Hasidic texts and why I’m so into that tradition.
I miss that. I never really had the opportunity to do it because I was a kid, but I wish I had a place where I could say, “Let me share my testimony.”
I turn it into divrei Torah and do it in other ways, but it’s couched in a whole lot of “I’m not trying to say this” and “God is…” There’s a lot of qualification.
Sometimes I just wish I could yell and scream and run up and down the aisles, you know?
I didn’t intend to ask many questions about the intersection of race and religion but I find it very interesting.
I’m working on a PhD, and I’m going to finish it. I need to put that out into the universe.
It’s about disentangling whiteness and Jewishness because I feel that the fact that they’re so entangled is partly connected to the history of antisemitism. I don’t want to say it’s because antisemitism has existed forever and will unfortunately continue to exist, but in this country, I think that history feeds into the problem.
When people say terrible things about Jews, it’s often because Jews are seen as white, and it’s considered acceptable to talk about the oppressor.
But that’s not really who Jews are.
Have you experienced antisemitism yourself?
It’s interesting. I’ve never experienced… Well, what is the level of antisemitism?
I remember, very early on, going to shul on Easter. The bus driver asked me, “Why aren’t you in church?”
I said, “I’m ewish… I’m going to shul.”
He was like, “You’re not Jewish? What are you talking about?” and went on and on.
So there was that.
Even in my family, one of my cousins, a while back after I converted, suddenly started making everything about Israel. I didn’t even know what Israel was doing back then, but Israel is always doing something.
My cousin asked, “How do you feel about Israel? Why do we have to invite her to the family gathering?”
Thank God, my uncle said, “Because that’s your cousin.”
There’s that.
It’s a challenge because there’s a lot of antisemitism, anti-Jewish sentiment, and anti-Israel sentiment. Untangling those things is difficult. What is legitimate criticism of Israel, and what is actually antisemitism? There’s a lot of that in the Black community, too, because of solidarity with Palestinians and Palestinian lives.
I often feel that I have to defend Israel and defend my right to be Jewish when I’m in conversations with Black people I don’t know, outside a spiritual context.
When we gather as clergy, I don’t feel that. But when I’m talking to a random Black person, it’s like, “Oh, so how do you feel about this?”
I don’t know another religion that automatically has to become so political.
I’m sure there are others, and Muslims have certainly had to deal with it.
It’s stressful. Even today, I was thinking, “Do I wear a Star of David somewhere where I don’t know the people? Is it going to turn into where I have to defend myself, my beliefs, and my identity?”
I can imagine there are times when you just need a break.
Yeah.
Together with that, I understand when people say, “Can we just be white?” I get that. But what’s the long-term cost of that?
It’s good that we’re having this conversation.
It sucks that we have to.
And I think that’s another thing that has always attracted me to Judaism. It’s one of those connections I continue to make.
As you said, Judaism as a religion is immediately political. Being Black is also immediately political. Those two things go together for me.
It sucks when they’re in tension.
Very much.
It’s not something you asked for.